VMware Cloud Offerings comparison & reviews

Summary
Rank
2nd 3rd 1st
Score
0%
0%
User Reviews
Question?
Not Enabled Not Enabled Not Enabled
Analysis expand by Graham Barker by Graham Barker by Graham Barker
Select All
General expand
0%
0%
0%
  • Fully Supported
  • Limitation
  • Not Supported
  • Information Only
Pros
  • + Implemented by approved VMware partner.
  • + Some 3rd party & IBM solutions supported.
  • + Full root access available.
  • + Customizable SDDC offering with flexible datacenter options.
  • + Bolt-on services such as OS patching of Virtual Machines
  • + Migration options and support avalable
  • + Full bare-metal SDDC deployed within approx 1.5 hours.
  • + Hardware hosted by leading cloud provider (AWS)
  • + Full self-service
Cons
  • - No host autoscaling.
  • - No automated remediation.
  • - 24 hour deployment times.
  • - Restricted permissions
  • - Multiple add-ons can be costly
  • - Long deployment times
  • - No root access.
  • - Minimum 3 hosts required at this time.
  • - Bandwidth charges apply
  Content  
  •  
Demo Site
Yes, demo site available: https://www.ibm.com/cloud/garage/demo/try-vmware-solutions/
No public demo site
Yes, via VMware Hands on Labs link: http://www.vmware.com/go/try-vmc-aws-hol?src=af_5b3151915643d&cid=70134000001YUWE
  •  
Content Creator
WhatMatrix Contributor: Graham Barker
WhatMatrix Contributor: Graham Barker
WhatMatrix Contributor: Graham Barker
  •  
Offering Overview
Based on VMware Cloud Foundation and IBM Infrastruture, the service combines VMware vSphere, vSAN and NSX into a full SDDC cloud offering
Rackspace offer a feature rich VMware cloud solution which can be located within their datacenters or within a co-located datacenter. Their solution extends from the VMware suite right down into the application layer if required.
VMware Cloud on AWS is a service offered and billed by VMware which includes a full SDDC, hosted within AWS regions
Offering expand
0%
0%
0%
  Assessment  
  •  
Maturity
Solution is GA as of October 2016
Solution is GA
GA August 2017
  •  
Global Availability
Worldwide
IAD, DFW, LON, ORD, SDY and HKG + custom datacenters
AWS Asia Pacific (Sydney) Region, AWS US East (N. Virginia) region, AWS US West (Oregon) region, AWS EU (London) region and AWS EU (Frankfurt) Region.
  Asseessment  
  •  
Cloud Provider
IBM have been offering cloud solutions since 2005. This solution was first to market and went GA in 2016
Rackspace is one of the UK leaders in Cloud Services, established in 1999 with a full support portfolio and 3000+ dedicated hosting engineers
AWS & VMware are well established and leaders in their respective fields. The entier solution is over 1 year old but built on tried and tested software and hardware
  •  
Cloud Type
Private, hosted cloud
Private, hosted cloud
Private, hosted cloud
  Commercial  
  •  
Contract Periods
Custom contracts are available. Typical monthly contracts are provided
Flexible contract options
On-demand or 1 / 3 year subscription. 30 day single host proof of concept also available
  •  
Solution Pricing
On demand starts at $3.71 per host per hour. A minimum of 3 hosts is required for production use. This price includes licensing costs (Varying host sizes available)
Pricing is not public. Contact vendor directly
On-demand starts at $8.3681 per host per hour. A minimum of 3 hosts is required for production use. This price includes licensing costs. (Varying host sizes available)
  Contractual relationship  
  •  
IaaS Contract
IBM
Rackspace
AWS
  •  
VMware Contract
IBM
Rackspace
VMware
  Operational Model  
  •  
Self / Managed Service
Day to day operatons are completed by the customer. Hardware, software patching and fault resolution is provided by IBM. Fully managed services available from IBM also
Hardware and VMware components managed and serviced by Rackspace
Day to day operatons are completed by the customer. Hardware and software patching and fault reslution is provided by VMware
Operations expand
0%
0%
0%
  Management  
  •  
Cloud Access
VMware portal is integrated into IBM Cloud portal to perform most actions
No Vendor portal integration
Vendor portal integration for most actions is available
  •  
VMware Management
Native VMware Client(s) + APIs
Native VMware Client(s) + APIs
Native VMware Client(s) + APIs
  Deployment  
  •  
Deployment Time
SDDC deployment times are up to 24 hours
SDDC can be installed in a mutually agreed datacenter which will affect deployment times
A full SDDC is deployed within 1.5 hours
  •  
Deployment Guidance
Deploiyment is handled by IBM using VMware Cloud Foundation. Standard deployments are fully automated
Deploiyment is handled by Rackspace using VMware Cloud Foundation
Fully automated deployment and expansion
  Level of Access  
  •  
SSH Access (ESX Shell)
Full root access is available
Limited permissions
No root access
  •  
Host Reboot
IBM provide reboot options to the customer
Rackspace assisted
Yes however updates are managed by VMware as part of the contract.
  Support  
  •  
Support Options
SDDC Hardware and Software fully supported by IBM
Hardware and software support provided by Rackspace. Addditional support options also available
Full hardware and VMware software support. Both provided by VMware as a single contact for support
  •  
Documentation & Community
8/10 Most tasks are documented.
7 out of 10
9 out of 10.
The solution is fully documented, available in the public domain and has a very active community
  Licensing  
  •  
Licenses Provided
Licenses included
Licenses includes
Licenses included
  •  
BYOL
Yes, BYOL is permitted
No. Licenses must be purchased from Rackspace
Own licenses can be traded in for discounts to the service pricing
  Migration  
  •  
Migration Options
HCX (Additional cost) Zerto, Cross vCenter vMotion and SRM with vSphere Replication are fully supported as options by IBM
Migration options available via Rackspace Professional Services
Cross vCenter / Region vMotion through vSphere UI, PowerCLI or VMware Hybrid Cloud Extension. SRM with vSphere Replication also supported.
  Services  
  •  
Service Options
Single Vendor for hardware and software
OS patching, administration and mopnitoring services available. Antivirus add-ons also available
Hardware and software fully supported by VMware directly
Deployment expand
0%
0%
0%
  Automation  
  •  
Automation Level
Deployment is mostly automated
Deployed by Rackspace, Not fully automated
Fully automated deployment
  •  
Deployment Time
Full SDDC up to 24 hours. Additional hosts approx 1 hour
Deployment requires engagement with vendor which impacts deployment time
Full SDDC approx 1.5 hours. Additional hosts approx 10 minutes
  •  
Deployment Guidance
Guided deployment
Vendor assisted deployment
Simple guided deployment and "Hands on Lab" available for full detail.
  Automation VMware  
  •  
Hypervisor
Hypervisors deployed, installed and configured automatically by vendor
Hypervisors deployed, installed and configured automatically by vendor
Hypervisors deployed, installed and configured automatically by vendor
  •  
vCenter Management
vCenter is deployed with SSO enabled
vCenter is deployed with SSO enabled
vCenter is deployed with SSO enabled
  •  
vSAN
vSAN deployed, installed and configured automatically
vSAN deployed, installed and configured automatically
vSAN deployed, installed and configured automatically
  •  
NSX
NSX deployed, installed and configured automatically
NSX deployed, installed and configured automatically
NSX deployed, installed and configured automatically
  •  
vRA
vRA not automatically deployed
vRA not automatically deployed
vRA not automatically deployed
  •  
HICX
HCX options available at additional costs
HCX options unknown
HCX available at no additional cost
  Automation 3rd Party  
  •  
Backup
Veeam and Zerto options available during deployment
Backup & DR options offered via "bolt-on" services
SRM available. 3rd party partner solutions for backup also available
  •  
DR
Zerto and Veeam (Add on) available during deployment. SRM with vSphere Replication also available.
Backup & DR options offered via "bolt-on" services
SRM deployed, installed and configured (Add on)
  •  
Other?
IBM and 3rd party integration options are available
3rd party options can be integrated provided they will operate within restricted permission set.
All officially supported 3rd party solutions available here: https://cloud.vmware.com/vmc-aws/solutions#technology-solutions
Architecture expand
0%
0%
0%
  Scalability  
  •  
Min host count
A minimum of 4 hosts is recommended however 2 and 3 host clusters are possible
4 host minimum
3 hosts for production or 1 host for 30 day "proof of concept"
  •  
Max host count
32 hosts per cluster
Maximum hosts unknown
32 Hosts per cluster
  •  
Multi-Cluster
Max 5 clusters per site
Maximum clusters unknown
Yes and multiple SDDCs supported
  •  
Multi-Site
Multi site is available. Stretched vSAN clusters are also available (Not yet fully automated)
Multi-site options unknown
Yes, multiple availability zones possible with stretched vSAN clusters
  Flexibility  
  •  
Add Host
Yes, automated after manual selection. No current DRS automation for adding new hosts
Yes, automation options unknown
Adding hosts is fully automated. DRS rules can automatically add new hosts.
  •  
Remove Host
Yes, hosts can be removed
Removal of hosts is possible. Automation level is unknown
Removal of hosts is fully automated
  •  
Autoscale
No autoscaling at this time
No autoscaling at this time
Yes, adding hosts can be automatically added based on criteria
  Compute  
  •  
Host Size
Variable hosts sizes available including highly configurable options
Unknown
Standard I3.metal and newer R5.Metal instances
  Storage  
  •  
Storage Options other
DR add-on available (Zerto / Veeam / SRM)
Backup and DR options available
DR add-on available via SRM and verified 3rd partiy solutions
  Networking  
  •  
Speed & Separation
NIOC available
NIOC available
NIOC available. Low latency networking into AWS via ENA
  •  
SDN
NSX included
NSX included with solution
NSX included
  Security & Access  
  •  
Security Model
VLAN, RBAC, NSX options included.
VLAN, RBAC, NSX options included
VLAN, RBAC, NSX, Data at Rest Encryption
  •  
Public Access / Ipsec
Yes. For security purposes a VPN is required
Yes. For security purposes a VPN is required
Yes. For security purposes a VPN is required
  •  
Private Access / MPLS
Yes, via Leased Line
Yes, via Leased Line
Yes
  •  
Traffic Separation (host)
NIOC (Network IO Control)
NIOC (Network IO Control)
NIOC (Network IO Control)
  •  
Muli-Tenancy
Not officially supported at this time
Not available, this is a dedicated infrastructure solution
Not officially supported at this time
  Vmware Functionality  
  •  
DRS
Yes
Yes
Yes
  •  
HA
Yes
Yes
Yes
  •  
Long Distance VMotion
Yes
Unknown
Yes
  •  
Stretched Cluster
Yes, but not automatically deployed
Unknown
Yes
Add-Ons expand
0%
0%
0%
  3nd Party  
  •  
DR
Zerto, Veeam and SRM options available
Rackspace managed DR (vSphere Replication with SRM) is available
vSphere SRM & Dell EMC Data Domain Cloud Disaster Recovery
  3rd Party  
  •  
Backup
Veeam and Zerto offerings available
Rackspace Managed backup available.
Veeam and Dell EMC Avamar & Networker
  •  
Security
F5, FortiGate, HyTrust, KMIP add ons are available
3rd party options which are not supported may be installed at own risk
Checkpoint, F5, Palo Alto, Trend Micro
  4th Party  
  •  
Other
Various offerings available
3rd party options not supported but may be installed at own risk
All officially supported 3rd party solutions available here: https://cloud.vmware.com/vmc-aws/solutions#technology-solutions

Matrix Score

  •  
  •  
  • IBM
  • Rackspace
  • VMware
  •  
  • 2 nd
  • 3 rd
  • 1 st
X
Login to access your personal profile

Forgot your Password?
X
Signup with linkedin
X

Registered, but not activated? click here (resend activation link)

Login to access your personal profile

Receive new comparison alerts

Show me as community member

I agree to your Terms of services

GDPR